"AisleWizard is supported by its readers. Please assume all links are affiliate links. If you purchase something from one of our links we make a small commission from Amazon."

Does Trader Joe’s Eye Cream Work? (Explained)

Does Trader Joe's Eye Cream Work

If you’re a person who is sensitive about their skincare routine, you must also be skeptical of what eye cream brands you use for your daily skincare, while also making sure to remain within your budget, since skincare can be very expensive. In this regard, Trader Joe’s Supreme Hydrating eye cream is a great choice if you’re both money conscious and skin sensitive.

Trader Joe’s Supreme Hydrating eye cream contains plant extracts, collagen, and various other natural ingredients. This makes it a good choice for people with dry under-eyes who want something hydrating, making for good reviews within its customers. The eye cream also leaves you with glowing and softer skin, acting as a moisturizer for the skin around your eyes.

Stay with us to find out more about Trader Joe’s Supreme Hydrating eye cream, how it works, what ingredients make it so special, and what the people have to say about it. We’ll also be giving you a few tips and things to take into consideration before purchasing an eye cream, to make your choice easier. 

What is Trader Joe’s Eye Cream and What Does It Claim to Do?

Click Image for More Info

Trader Joe’s has an eye cream under their brand which claims to be Supreme Hydrating, being a moisturizer, a hydrating mix, and an eye cream all in one. The eye cream is a part of their beauty and personal care line, and costs around $5.99, considered a reasonable price to pay compared to many other eye creams. 

The eye cream claims to be ‘Supreme Hydrating’ and promises quick absorption, leaving you with a soft and moisturized under eye area.

It also promises no breakouts, and a smoother finish compared to other eye creams, claiming to be the best for people with sensitive skin.

It’s important to note that this eye cream, as claimed by its manufacturer, Trader Joe’s, is completely alcohol-free and is not tested on animals, so it is also cruelty-free.

To check the current price and availability of Trader Joe’s Hydrating Eye Cream, click here to view the listing on Amazon.

Ingredients in Trader Joe’s Eye Cream

Their eye cream contains a mix of artificial and natural ingredients, listed below with their purposes:

  • Water (Aqua) – solvent (for cosmetic products)
  • Dicaprylyl Carbonate – emollient (solubilizes products and gives a smooth feel)   
  • Betaine – moisturizer (controls water balance in cells)
  • Glycerin – moisturizer 
  • Cetearyl Alcohol – emulsifier and cleanser (cleans pores and softens skin)
  • Prunus Amygdalus Dulcis – emollient
  • Cetyl Alcohol – viscosity controlling emollient (acts as a non-drying agent)
  • Cetearyl Olivate – emulsifier (helps oils and water mix)
  • Isopropyl Myristate – scenting (acts as a perfume)
  • Isoamyl Laurate – emollient       
  • Sorbitan Olivate – emulsifier
  • Glyceryl Caprylate – preservative (multi-purpose ingredient)   
  • Shea Butter – emollient
  • Triethanolamine – buffering (sets solution’s pH to alkaline)
  • Argan Kernel Oil – antioxidant (vitamin E) and emollient
  • Marula Seed Oil    – emollient
  • Carbomer    – viscosity control
  • Manuka Honey – soothing moisturizer and ​antibacterial     (gets rid of bacteria on skin)
  • Fragrance (Parfum) – scenting 
  • Caprylhydroxamic Acid    – chelating (preserves cosmetic product)   
  • Vitamin E – antioxidant
  • Sodium Citrate – chelating and buffering       
  • Rosehip Seed Oil – emollient
  • Hydrolyzed Collagen – emollient and moisturizer
  • Squalane – emollient
  • Dextrin – viscosity controller and moisturizer   
  • Ubiquinone – antioxidant
  • Seed Polysaccharide and Hydrolyzed Hibiscus Extract

Reviews of Trader Joe’s Eye Cream

Various customer who have tried and Trader Joe’s Supreme Hydrating eye cream have a lot to say about it, and we’ll be summarizing those reviews as follows.

Customers who have used other eye creams which are more towards the high-end product list (being more expensive and exclusive), say that although this cream does not have all the high-end ingredients as its competitors, it has a lot of plant-based natural and organic ingredients which adds to its appeal.

Plus, it also costs less than its competitor eye creams.

Although the cream is suitable for both night and day use, people noticed that it works the best during the night, given ample time to be absorbed into the skin and re-hydrate it.

The cream worked better for people with more dryness under their eyes, for which they had to use the cream twice a day, and it works better at hydrating and moisturizing, as the name suggests.

Working at only rehydrating, the cream does not deal with or solve the issue of under eye darkness. It does not make the eye bags go away either, leaving the puffiness as is, however, customers reported that the cream does not cause break-outs, being sensitive skin-friendly.

A user reported that the cream also had no strong smells and felt good on the face when applied.

Customers reported that the cruelty-free and the alcohol-free ingredients also make it a good night or day eye cream to use, since alcohol can be irritable to people with sensitive skin.

Considerations for Using Eye Creams

Before you incorporate an eye cream into your skincare routine, here are 4 considerations to keep in mind:

  1. Make sure that the eye cream does not cause makeup creases for day uses.
  2. Apply the eye cream gently onto your under-eye, since it’s a sensitive area.
  3. Don’t expect results in a day or two, give the product some time to take effect.
  4. Don’t break your bank choosing an eye cream worth a lot of money.

Tips for Choosing an Effective Eye Cream

Before you’re choosing an eye cream to buy, think thoroughly about what it is that you actually expect of a product:

  1. If you want to solve your dark circle problems, buy an eye cream that has natural, organic ingredients which brighten up the under-eyes.
  2. If you want to get rid of the dryness around your eyes, choose a moisturizing eye cream like Trader Joe’s.
  3. If you want to get rid of the puffiness under the eyes, choose a night cream which calms your skin cells and reduces puffing up.
  4. If you need to solve the problem of wrinkles around your eyes, choose an eye cream packed with antioxidants.
  5. If your skin is more sensitive than the others, choose an eye cream which has ‘for sensitive skin’ written on it, or one without irritants like alcohol.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should You Put Eye Cream on Eyelids?

Yes, it should be ok to use the product on your eyelids, however, you should always read the label first to see if it’s safe for the eyelids, and how much product is recommended to be used on that area.

Final Thoughts

By now we hope you’ve found out all there is to know about Trader Joe’s Supreme Hydrating eye cream, what it does, and how it works to hydrate your under-eyes and save it from flaking dry skin.

If hydration isn’t your main concern, there are other eye creams on the market which specifically deal with eye bags, darkened under eyes, and wrinkles.

However, Trader Joe’s eye cream, as per customer reviews, has been proven to be an all-rounder, and an item which helps revitalize your skin while also keeping its sensitivity under consideration. We hope that you to use this information to help you in your future purchases. Good luck!


Shane is a fitness enthusiast who also has a passion for trying and cooking new foods. His favorite stores to shop at include Trader Joe's, Wholefoods Market, Sprouts, Stater Brothers, and Target.

Recent Posts