"AisleWizard is supported by its readers. Please assume all links are affiliate links. If you purchase something from one of our links we make a small commission from Amazon."

Does Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Expire? (Answered)

Does Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Expire

Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter has long been beloved by shoppers as a delicious yet affordable indulgence. However, what is less well known is whether or not it expires.

The answer is yes- while the ingredients used in their cookie butter are all shelf stable, manufacturers suggest that it should be consumed within nine months of purchase for optimal freshness and flavor. Fortunately, because Cookie Butter only consists of sugar, vegetable oil, palm oil shortening, emulsifier and salt – as well as some natural flavorings – it can typically last longer than other similar products.

All in all, Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter may taste best when used before the expiration date printed on the packaging, but ultimately might still be edible for up to one year past that date if stored properly in the pantry or refrigerator.

Expiration Dates on Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Packages

Trader Joe’s cookie butter packages come with expiration dates printed on them, although this label language can be confusing.

According to Trader Joe’s, the expiration date set on their products is the “best before” date, meaning that the product should be consumed by then, but may still be safe and of good quality to consume after this date has passed.

The expiration date is also indicated in a Julian calendar format rather than MM/DD/YYYY format commonly used in the United States for consumer goods.

This numbering system starts from January 1st as 001 and ends on December 31st as 365; so if you purchase your Trader Joe’s cookie butter at the start of May it would have an expiration date of 149 according to this calendar.

It’s important to note that even after passing its expiration date the cookie butter might be completely fine, but it is best to consult the manufacturers website or contact their customer service for more info.

How to Tell if Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Has Expired

Click Image for More Info

If you’re not sure if your Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter has gone bad, look out for specific signs. Fresh Cookie Butter should have a smooth, creamy consistency without any lumps or discoloration. Its sweet, cinnamon smell should be strong and distinctive when you open the jar.

If it looks, smells, or tastes off in any way, throw it out to avoid any potential illnesses. In addition, check the container for an expiration date; it might be hidden on the bottom of the jar among the nutritional information.

If you cannot locate an expiration date, it is best to err on the side of caution and discard Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter that is several months old.

To check the current price and availability of Trader Joe’s Speculoos Cookie Butter, click here to view the listing on Amazon.

Storing Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter to Prolong Its Shelf Life

To make sure that your container of Cookie Butter stays fresh for as long as possible, it is important to store it according to the instructions on the label.

Whenever possible, try to keep the jar sealed to minimize exposure to air. Keeping it in a cool dark place will also help protect it from light or temperature changes that might degrade its taste.

As an added layer of protection, transferring Cookie Butter from its original package into a glass or metal container with a tight lid can further extend its shelf life.

No matter what storage method you choose, look at the expiration date on the jar before using it to make sure that you are still within safe guidelines.

Freezing Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter to Extend Its Shelf Life

The freezing technique doesn’t require any specific steps; just store the jar or container of Cookie Butter in the freezer overnight and the next day you can enjoy the same creamy, delicious texture and flavor as if you had purchased it fresh.

You can also freeze individual spoonfuls of Cookie Butter on a cookie sheet lined with parchment paper, then store them in a tightly sealed plastic bag or container once frozen. This helps ensure that you have easy access to single servings while also avoiding thawing out the entire jar all at once.

Using Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter After Its Expiration Date

It is important to note that eating Trader Joe’s cookie butter past its expiration date can be dangerous. The texture and consistency of the spread will start to change, and consumption of spoiled food can cause serious health complications.

After the expiration date has passed, any leftover cookie butter should be thrown away in an effort to prevent potentially fatal food-borne illnesses. 

Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Does Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Last?

Most packages of Trader Joe’s cookie butter can be kept at room temperature in an airtight container for 3-4 months.

After opening, if any leftovers remain, it should be stored in the refrigerator where it can keep for up to 6 months.

Since expiration dates are not included on the package, one of the best indicators is taste testing to see if its still enjoyable.

Can You Eat Cookie Butter Past Expiration Date?

Most products with a high sugar content, such as cookie butter, have microbial stability: meaning they have a longer shelf life than other types of food.

Generally speaking, if the product smells and tastes fine even after its listed expiration date, then it should still be safe to consume; however, it’s always best to err on the caution side and throw away any products that are expired or past their best-by dates.

How Long Can You Keep Cookie Butter?

While its delicious flavor and texture may cause it to be eaten quickly, you can actually keep the jar of cookie butter in your cupboard for up to 12 months before it begins to spoil.

The deliciousness of the cookie butter relies on its combination of spices, sugar, and oil; they all need to remain properly sealed and stored away from light and heat to maintain their best quality.

You can store cookie butter in the fridge if you want it to remain fresh for up to 18 months but be aware that this results in a firmer texture. 

Why Not Refrigerate Cookie Butter?

 Though it may be tempting to keep a jar in the refrigerator for a cool taste, doing so could ruin its taste and consistency. Cookie butter is best stored at room temperature due to its high saturated fat content; when exposed to cold temperatures, it can become firm and harden into an undesirable shape.

Additionally, if placed in the refrigerator the cookie butter may absorb the scent of other foods kept there, weakening the flavor of its nutty sweetness. 


Shane is a fitness enthusiast who also has a passion for trying and cooking new foods. His favorite stores to shop at include Trader Joe's, Wholefoods Market, Sprouts, Stater Brothers, and Target.

Recent Posts